Get Your Cash Offer in Minutes - No Repairs, No Fees
Get My Offer
Get Your Cash Offer
Property Disputes & Co-Ownership

What Happens When One Co-Owner Wants to Sell a House and the Other Doesn't?

What if one co-owner wants to sell a house and the other refuses? Learn about buyouts, partition actions, inherited property, and selling in Mississippi.

10:00 AM By Back to Blog
One Co-Owner Wants to Sell a House and the Other Doesn't

Owning a house with someone else can seem like a good idea until you disagree about what to do with the property. One person may need money, want to move, or simply be ready to sell, while the other wants to keep the home.

So, what happens when one co-owner wants to sell a house and the other doesn't?

Can one person force a sale? Does the other owner have the right to refuse? And what happens if neither person is willing to compromise?

The answers depend on how the property is owned, the state where it is located, and whether the owners are spouses, relatives, or unrelated individuals.

If you're dealing with this situation in Mississippi, there may be several ways to resolve the disagreement without letting the property become a long-term financial burden.

Can One Co-Owner Sell a House Without the Other's Permission?

In most situations, one co-owner cannot independently sell the entire property without the other owner's consent.

When two or more people own a house together, each person has a legal ownership interest. The deed generally identifies the owners and may help establish how those interests are held.

For example, imagine two siblings inherit a house from their parents. One sibling wants to sell the property and divide the money, but the other wants to keep the family home.

Neither sibling should assume they can sign away the other's ownership interest.

However, the person who wants to sell may have options, including negotiating a buyout or exploring a legal partition action.

The exact rights depend on the deed, ownership arrangement, inheritance documents, and applicable state law.

1. Understand How the Property Is Owned

Before deciding what to do, find out how the house is legally owned.

Different ownership arrangements can affect whether a person can sell, transfer, or request a division of the property.

Here are some common situations.

Joint Tenants

Joint tenants own property together, sometimes with a right of survivorship. Depending on the deed and state law, when one owner dies, their interest may pass to the surviving owner or owners.

Tenants in Common

Tenants in common each own an undivided share of the property. Their ownership percentages may be equal or different.

For example, two siblings may each own 50% of a house, while three relatives may own different percentages based on an inheritance or other agreement.

A tenant in common may have the ability to transfer their own ownership interest, subject to applicable law and existing agreements. That does not automatically give them authority to sell the entire house.

Property Owned by Married Couples

When spouses own a house together, divorce, separation, marital property rules, and homestead protections can affect how the property is sold or divided.

A spouse's ownership rights may not be determined by the deed alone. Court orders and state marital property laws may also matter.

Important: Don't assume that every co-owner has the same rights. Review the deed and consult a real estate attorney before making decisions.

2. Try to Negotiate a Buyout

One of the simplest ways to resolve a disagreement is for the owner who wants to keep the house to buy out the other person's share.

This allows one person to receive money for their ownership interest while the other keeps the property.

For example:

Imagine two siblings jointly own a house worth $200,000. They each have a 50% ownership interest.

One sibling wants to sell, but the other wants to remain in the house.

They could agree that the sibling staying in the property purchases the other sibling's interest for an agreed amount.

However, the actual buyout amount should account for the property's value, outstanding mortgage, liens, ownership percentages, and any agreed adjustments.

Before completing a buyout, consider:

  • Getting an independent property valuation.
  • Reviewing the mortgage balance.
  • Checking for unpaid taxes or liens.
  • Preparing a written buyout agreement.
  • Consulting a real estate attorney about transferring ownership.
  • Speaking with the lender about any mortgage or refinancing requirements.

A buyout can help avoid a lengthy disagreement and allow both owners to move forward.

3. Discuss Selling the Property and Dividing the Money

If neither owner wants to purchase the other's share, selling the entire property may be a practical solution.

Both owners can agree on:

  • A realistic asking price.
  • Whether to work with a real estate agent.
  • Which repairs, if any, should be completed.
  • How the property will be shown to potential buyers.
  • How the sale proceeds will be divided.

For example, if two owners have equal ownership interests, they may agree to divide the net proceeds equally after paying the mortgage, closing expenses, liens, and other obligations.

The division may be different if the ownership percentages are unequal or a court order or agreement provides otherwise.

A written agreement can help prevent misunderstandings about the sale price, expenses, and distribution of money.

4. What If the Other Co-Owner Refuses to Sell?

This is where things can become more complicated.

If one owner refuses to sell, the other owner may have the option of requesting a legal partition of the property.

A partition action is a court proceeding that can address disagreements between people who jointly own real estate.

Depending on the circumstances, the court may consider two main approaches.

Partition in Kind

Partition in kind means physically dividing the property into separate portions so that each owner receives an appropriate share.

This may be possible with larger parcels of land, but it is often impractical for a single-family house.

Partition by Sale

Partition by sale means selling the property and distributing the proceeds according to the owners' legal interests, subject to applicable costs and court orders.

However, a court does not automatically order a sale simply because one person wants one.

The court must consider the applicable legal requirements and circumstances of the property.

In Mississippi, partition proceedings are generally handled through chancery court. Mississippi law recognizes partition rights, but the preferred approach and available remedies depend on the type of ownership and property involved.

A Mississippi Court of Appeals decision, Wade v. Simmons Erosion Control, Inc. (2024), illustrates how a court can consider a physical division of jointly owned land and evaluate whether the proposed portions fairly reflect each owner's interest.

If you are considering a partition action, speak with a Mississippi real estate attorney before filing.

5. Special Rules May Apply to Inherited Family Property

Inherited houses can create particularly difficult disagreements.

For example, parents may leave a house to three children. One child wants to sell and receive their share of the inheritance, while the other two want to keep the property in the family.

This type of ownership is sometimes called heirs' property.

Mississippi adopted the Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act, which applies to qualifying heirs' property partition actions filed on or after July 1, 2020.

The law includes protections and procedures that can affect how the property is valued, whether other co-owners can buy out the person seeking a sale, and whether the property should be physically divided or sold.

For qualifying cases, Mississippi Code Sections 91-31-13 and 91-31-15 provide a court-supervised buyout process and rules for determining whether partition in kind or partition by sale is appropriate.

This means that an inherited property dispute may involve additional steps beyond an ordinary disagreement between co-owners.

If you inherited a house with siblings or other relatives, it is important to establish who legally owns the property before attempting to sell it.

6. Consider Whether Selling One Ownership Share Is an Option

Sometimes, the person who wants to sell is willing to consider selling only their ownership interest.

For example, one person owns 50% of a house and wants to receive money without waiting for the other owner to agree to a full-property sale.

Depending on the ownership arrangement and applicable law, transferring an individual ownership interest may be possible.

However, selling a partial interest can be difficult.

Many traditional homebuyers are not interested in purchasing a share of a property when another person continues to own and occupy it.

A buyer may also consider the legal and practical challenges of sharing ownership with someone they do not know.

Before considering this option, understand the value of your ownership interest and consult an attorney about any restrictions, agreements, or transfer requirements.

7. Understand the Financial Responsibilities While You Disagree

A disagreement about selling does not automatically remove the owners' financial responsibilities.

While the property remains jointly owned, there may still be expenses to manage.

These can include:

  • Mortgage payments.
  • Property taxes.
  • Homeowners insurance.
  • Utilities.
  • Necessary maintenance.
  • Repairs and upkeep.

If one owner pays all the expenses while the other owner refuses to contribute, that issue may need to be addressed through an accounting or contribution claim, especially if the property is later sold or divided.

Keeping receipts and payment records can help document what each owner paid during the period of co-ownership.

8. Can a Cash Home Buyer Help When Co-Owners Disagree?

If both owners eventually decide that selling is the best option, a direct sale to a cash home buyer may be worth considering.

Potential advantages of a direct cash sale may include:

  • Selling the house as-is without paying for repairs.
  • Avoiding real estate agent commissions.
  • Choosing a closing date that works for both owners.
  • Avoiding some delays associated with traditional buyer financing.

However, a cash buyer cannot automatically override another owner's legal rights. If both owners' signatures or a court order are required, those requirements still need to be satisfied.

Compare the offer, deductions, closing costs, and expected net proceeds before making a decision.

9. Steps to Take Before Making a Final Decision

If you and another person disagree about selling a jointly owned house, take a few practical steps before the situation gets worse.

  1. Step 1: Review the deed. Confirm who owns the property and whether ownership percentages or survivorship rights are stated.
  2. Step 2: Determine the property's value. Consider an independent appraisal or a comparative market analysis.
  3. Step 3: Review outstanding expenses. Check the mortgage balance, property taxes, insurance, liens, and necessary repairs.
  4. Step 4: Talk about a buyout. Find out whether the owner who wants to keep the property can purchase the other person's share.
  5. Step 5: Put agreements in writing. Record any decisions about the price, expenses, closing, and distribution of proceeds.
  6. Step 6: Get legal advice. If the disagreement continues, a real estate attorney can explain whether negotiation, mediation, or a partition action may be appropriate.

Taking these steps early may help prevent a disagreement from turning into a costly legal dispute.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Can one person force the sale of a jointly owned house?

In some circumstances, yes. A co-owner may be able to file a partition action asking a court to divide or sell the property. Whether a sale is ordered depends on the ownership arrangement, applicable state law, and the facts of the case.

2. Can I sell my share of a house without the other owner's permission?

Depending on the ownership arrangement and applicable law, you may be able to transfer your individual ownership interest. However, this does not give you the right to sell the entire property without the necessary authority or consent.

3. What happens if siblings inherit a house and one wants to sell?

The siblings can negotiate a buyout or agree to sell the property and divide the proceeds. If they cannot agree, a qualifying co-owner may have the option to pursue a partition action. Special heirs' property rules may apply.

4. Can a court make the other owner sell the house in Mississippi?

A Mississippi chancery court may order partition when the legal requirements are met. Depending on the circumstances, the court may consider dividing the property or ordering a sale. A sale is not automatic simply because one owner requests it.

5. Can one co-owner buy out the other owner's share?

Yes. Co-owners can negotiate a buyout based on the property's value and their respective ownership interests. The agreement should address mortgage obligations, liens, expenses, and the legal transfer of ownership.

6. Can I sell a jointly owned house if the other owner lives in it?

The fact that one owner lives in the property does not automatically eliminate the other owner's ownership rights. However, occupancy, agreements, marital rights, and court orders may affect the available options. Get legal advice before taking action.

7. Does a cash home buyer purchase a jointly owned house?

A cash home buyer may consider purchasing a jointly owned property, but the transaction must meet the applicable ownership, title, and signing requirements. If the co-owners disagree, that issue generally needs to be resolved first.

Final Thoughts: What Should You Do When One Co-Owner Wants to Sell?

When one co-owner wants to sell a house and the other doesn't, the situation can be frustrating, especially when family relationships or financial responsibilities are involved.

But you may have more than one option.

You can try negotiating a buyout, agree to sell and divide the proceeds, or explore legal partition if an agreement is not possible. The right approach depends on your ownership arrangement and the laws that apply to the property.

If you own a jointly held or inherited house in Mississippi and both owners are ready to consider selling, PCL Home Offer can help you explore a direct cash-sale option.

You can learn more about selling a property as-is and reviewing your options at PCL Home Offer.